What was the occasion? How did they react? Did you ever pitch a tent in front of them, due to them looking?
I walked out of the shower at an apartment I shared not knowing a female co-worker and her girlfriend were there . Surprised us all . When I returned dressed we all chatted then the co-worker asked to see my room . You can fill in the rest . That was the beginning of YEARS of co-mingling . Some years later she and her husband became "the other couple " for my wife and I !!!
It wasn’t tightie whities for me, it was snug boxer briefs and yes, very tented. I was very young and had a crush on one of the girls in the room. Okay I had a crush on any woman who smiled at me. when strip poker was suggested I was very nervous about it but I thought I had nothing to lose, being pretty good at cards. I was wrong, maybe it was rigged. When I lost my jeans, I hesitated to pulled them down and off the girls cheered and giggled and I had no choice. Down they went. My face had already been red, now it was very hot feeling. The other guy there said, “you better start playing better I don’t want to see that thing!” The girls roared. There were bare breasts and one girl was naked, legs apart. I found it rather difficult to concentrate. I lost my briefs. I stood up and hesitated, the girl I had a crush on shouted, “You gotta lose ‘em” . So I did. Amazing how much difference there can be between how your mind feels and how your penis feels about being seen.