I had to go with "other" out of the bands you named, I like My Chemical Romance the best, but then again I'm not really a modern rock sort of girl.
i had to go with other also... since i too aint really into the modern rock scene... i like maynard.... but i dont care for APC... if tool was up there i would have chosen that...
out of those, i chose green day, but mcr is second. i still picked other becuz i like other bands better.
RIght.... if i had to choose only from those CDs for which to listen to.. i'd probably smash my cd player with a sledge hammer.. just to prevent anyone else from choosing for me