greatest......

in your opinion who is the greatest?...
Singer: Robert Plant
Guitarist: eh, so hard but i think im gonna go with Eric Clapton
Bassist: Les Claypool
Drummer: John Bonham
Songwriter: Bob Dylan

 

singer-robert plant

guitarist-jimmy page
bassist-steve harris
drummer-john bonham
songwriter-elliot smith

 

Singer: Mick Jagger
Guitarist: Jimmy Hendrix
Bassist: John Myung
Drummer: Virgil Donati - Dave Weckl - Dennis Chambers ( i really cant decide :-/ )
Songwriter: Jim Morrison

 

Singer: Robert Plant
Guitarist: Jimmy Hendrix
Bass: Jack Bruce
Drummer: John Bonham
Keyboards: Keith Emerson
Songwriter: Bob Dylan

 

Singer: Grace Slick
Guitarist: Jimmy Page
Bassist: Roger Waters, even though I hate him for selling out
Drummer: my favoritest drummer ever is John "Bonzo"...but my other favorites are keith moon, ginger baker, and nick mason there are others, but you know
Songwriter: Bob Dylan

this isn't on here but...
organist: john paul jones
sitarist: george harrison

 

Singer: Neil Young
Guitarist: Larry "Ler" LaLonde
Bassist: Jaco Pastrious
Drummer: Danny Carey
Songwriter: Bob Dylan

 

Okay, I can only narrow it down to the top five in each catagory.

Singer: Robert Plant, Jon Anderson, Freddie Mercury, Jim Morrison, Ray Charles

Guitarist: Jimi Hendrix, Steve Howe, Michael Hedges, Trey Anastasio, John Frusciante

Bassist: Chris Squire, Flea, Les Claypool, John Entwistle, Geddy Lee

Drummer: Bill Bruford, Stewart Copeland, John Bonham, Jon Fishman, Larry Mullen Jr.

Songwriter: Bob Dylan, Lennon/McCartney, Andy Partridge, Joni Mitchell, Bob Marley

 

singer: robert plant or roger waters or kurt cobain
guitarist: Jimmy Page
bassist: jack bruce, paul mcartney, john paul jones, or john entwistle
drums: john bonham, keith moon, mickey hart
songwriter dylan, lennon/mcartney, page/plant
i couldnt decide

 

Singer: ROBERT PLANT
Guitarist JIMI HENDRIX
Bass: FLEA
Drums JOHN BONHAM
Song Writer: JOHN LENNON

 

What? You can't seriously believe that George Harrison beats Ravi Shankar...

 

Singer: Jim Morrison
Guitarist: Robby Krieger
Bass: Paul McCartney
Drummer: John Bonham+John Densmore
Keyboards: Ray Manzarek
Songwriter: Bob Dylan

 

singer - ron 'pigpen' mckernan
guitarist - james gurley
bassist - les claypool
drummer - mitch mitchell
songwriter - robert hunter

 

well I have heard a lot more from Harrison than of Shankar, and what I have heard from Shankar, I think he kicks ass, but of the music I have heard from Harrison I like him better. Do you think you can share any more of Shankar's work and maybe later I may think otherwise

 

How could I have forgotten Mitch Mitchell. I thought I left someone out. Thanks a lot.

 

Well, George was a great songwriter and musician, don't get me wrong, but he was definitely not as skilled with the sitar as Ravi Shankar. The legend goes that Shankar spent two years just learning how to hold the instrument and practiced twelve hours a day for seven years to learn to play it.

The only Shankar I have is what seems to be a rather rare LP called Six Ragas. I've downloaded some other ragas in the past, though, but I don't have them anymore. Try looking on Soulseek or some other file sharing program for some of Ravi Shankar's recordings.

 

singer - Neil Young, Bob Dylan
guitarist - Neil Young
bassist - Paul McCartney
drummer - Levon Helm
songwriter - Bob Dylan, Neil Young

 

singer-John Linnell,
guitarist- Chuck Berry
bassist-Sir Paul McCartney(thats the only one whos name I know)
drummer-Ringo
songwriter- John Lennon,Chris Carrabba

 

no prob man...

 

if i do 5 for each id have to say



singer-robert plant, jim morrison, cedric zavala, elliot smith, roger daltrey
guitarist-jimmy page, jimi hendrix, omar rodriguez lopez, pete townshend, eric clapton
bassist-steve harris, john paul jones, victor wooten, flea, jack bruce
drummer-john bonham, keith moon, jon theodore, travis barker, mitch mitchell
songwriter-elliot smith, bob dylan, nick drake, page/plant, jimi hendrix

 

you just listed 'the doors'... whoa