Planet Caravan - vote

Pantera or Sabbath?

kudos to sabbath for creating such a great tune, but the production on the pantera ver is way superior!

 

Sabbath's.

 

Sabbaths for sure, although I do agree that the production is far better on Pantera's version, you'd be foolish not to call on the original.

 

I'd have to agree.

 

I do think Cathedral's version of Solitude is almost as great as the original though.

 

Talking about covering Solitude, the Swedish black metal band Blodsrit has done an excellent cover of Candlemass' song by this name. Very aggressive, in contrast to the original. Check it out, and while you're at it, try the song Illdjarn from the same album (Helveteshymner) as well. Real good.

 

I love black sabbaths version in my opinion superior. But you cannot deny the panteras versioon either.

 

pantera

 

I like black sabbath's version more then pantera's

 

Pantera are good but sabbath's version is better

 

what a twisted world ya gotta live in to even come up with this - sabbath of course. Saying production is the reason its a better song is like saying you prefer a happy meal because the burger comes in a cheerful box!

 

Sabbath all day long.

 

Well, it was released about 25 years later...

 

there was some pretty high end equipment in '70. that doesn't mean they didnt record into junk though.

oh, and I prefer sabbath's

if you wanna hear really low quality, try sabbath's Live at last

 

black sabbath version is better

 

No question. Definitely Sabbath's. It's their psychedelic rock song.

 

i like sabbath' version

 

Black Sabbath.

the warmth and atmosphere of an analog recording is hard to copy.

 

You mean there's another version besides Black Sabbath's?

 

THIS!

No disrespect to Pantera but you can't beat the original.