Brokeback mountain or The sound of music?

Which is your favourite film - brokeback mountain or The sound of music?

 

Brokeback, I like cowboys:drool:

 

Really neither.

I dunno, I guess Brokeback because it might actually have some sex in it. Whatever, I don't care.

 

What he said.

 

The sound of music is one of my fav movies. Bareback mountain is amazingly dull.

 

at long last, it is one of the most boring films I have ever seen in my life
S

 

It's a romance movie, they're pretty much slow and tedious by definition (just like real relationships). If you want a decent gay romance movie, try Brief Encounter, although even that's way too long.

Can anyone actually think of a movie with a gay person in where their sexuality isn't a big deal/central to the plot?

 

I didnt care for either one....but , the sound of music managed to get on my nerves a lot more.......i could pass up both movies and watch Yentl.

 

Brokeback Mountain Defo. i loved it

 

..................No.

I'm gonna be trying to think of one for days now. Thanks.

 

Would it be the first time I'd made you think about something for days?

 

Brokeback Mountain because of the impact it had on the discussion of gay issues. It was too long and a bit boring, but it opened a lot of eyes in the straight comunity.

 

Lol.

A quick wank doesn't solve this one though.

 

The movie Happy Endings, it wasn't a big deal...

 

I don't believe they are a fair comparison. It's like asking if you prefer DELIVERANCE or DRIVING MISS DAISY (since they are both set in the south).
I could watch THE SOUND OF MUSIC over and over again. I'm afraid BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN--while incredibly personally moving to me--is not a film that has me leave with that feel good feeling.

 

BEETLEJUICE

 

out of the two, i would definitely have to say brokeback. but only b/c I don't like musicals *ears bleeding*

 

This is like asking: "Which do you like better clams or a broom?"

 

the posidion remake as a gay charater in it, which isn't central to the plot
oh and he doesn't die ethier which is what usually happens with a tocken gay in these movies
S

 

I was trying to think of examples myself, I haven't been to the movies in a while though, and most of the films I do see are horror movies, where happy endings aren't really on the cards for anyone. But it has kinda struck me that I can't really think of many.

I did get into an argument with someone about whether As Good As It Gets portrays homosexuality a positive or negative way. We didn't ever resolve that one.