Keira Knightley or Scarlett Johansson?

I totally know that. You look great

I think they're both beautiful too.

I just think Keira is unhealthy. No matter what anyone says about natural thinness... I do not believe she has it. Not to this degree.

 

I was meaning the ribs in her chest.

You may find this absolutely comical............

But I think (in these pics at least), KK looks a lot less healthy than Posh.

 

She looks so good in both of these pics.

I'm going with Keira just because I like brunettes

 

I don't think that's why, she was full bodied before and now she's lost all that weight.

I know a girl who is insanely thin but she's always been like that. For the past 5 years I've known her she hasn't changed and she gets teased about how much she eats but never gains weight from her friends. ha.

EDIT: I'd still pick KK, cheekbones. I love her cheekbones. I'd just make her cover up all the time.

 

i think neither.. im team Megan Fox

 

If I had to pick one it would be KK.
She is a little skinny, but she is quite tall for a women (5'7" SJ is 5'4").
I imagine in real life she doesn't look so frail.
She states she hasn't had and doesn't have a eating disorder, she is just naturally thin.

I usually go for the fuller lady, like SJ...
But SJ, in my eyes, is a little too much of a slut (Sorry S if this isn't true ).
I'd arrange to meet her in our hotel room on the 8th floor...and she'll have had sex with 4 different men on the way up.
KK, I don't percieve her to be sluttish.
So for that simple reason, on this occasion, KK wins out.

(I'm not that keen on SJ face either, tbh - a case of "nice body shame about the face").

 

what about her face do you not like?

 

i voted both look great. for their body types, they've rocked it. i don't think keira looks unhealthy, rather... fit. same with scarlett--her curves are womanly and complement her well.

 

Everything when put on one face..
Individually she has very nice features...just fails when they are all put on the same face.
IMO, it doesn't quite work.
Especially the mouth.

 

The fact it's completely stretching the page. :toetap05:

 

I choose Scarlett :cheers2:




Hotwater

 

i'll be the loner and say i'll take keira any day over scarlett. keira is just one of my favorite actresses as far as looks. mmm mmm yummy. and while i think she is a lovely woman, scarlett is just not my type. i love curves and everything... it's just the blondeness and pale skin... and the facial features just aren't what turns me on.

lauramay, it seems you have a personal vendetta against skinny people, and that saddens me. however, i will concede that in the pictures provided, keira does look pretty terrible. but she doesn't always look like that! people are finding the worst pictures of her to post up here lately, lol. so here's some better ones.

looking fit and fab

sexy as a badass



i think this is my all time fav though. oh so fucking gorgeous.

 

Guys like Johansson because she's a regular girl next door. Women like Kiera because she's a stuck up bitch.

 

You are not alone:
Go to the post before that huge picture.

 

Oh yea, well I wish she’d move in next door to me


Hotwater

 

In Lauras defence, she did say that the poll is unfair and biased and did put up some attractive, more normal pictures of Knightly. The point is that she's talking about when you're so skinny you can see ribs etc.

Besides, Lauramay isn't fat.

I said I prefer KK too. :cheers2:

 

Both are beautiful, but I think Scarlett out beauties Kiera.

 

I agree both are beautiful, different kinds of beauty.
but id say Scarlett Johansson is more sexy, Keira is more model-y.

 

Neither.
Keira Knightley I like sometimes but not enough to choose her. However, I haven't liked Scarlett since her Ghost World days. Shes gross and fake now.

 

If I was a lesbian, my ideal woman would be Drew Barrymore and not because I look identical to her (I'm not THAT cocky haha...) but because she is gorgeous and curvy and naturally beautiful.