Crosby, Stills, and Nash or Simon & Garfunkel?

the most difficult choice--I can't even answer.

 

Me neither.

 

why choose?! they both were/are great bands, with different musical stylings. i dig them both!

 

KC and the sunshine boys.

 

i said simon and garfunkel...just because of garfunkels hair...

 

Good argument

 

uhuh...well that's what i'm known for

 

Csny

 

Crosby Stills Nash & Young!!!! Bitches!!!!

 

Simon and Garfunkel are good for relaxing/going to sleep to. CSN are good for listening to during the day, when you aren't remotely sleepy. CSN is more enjoyable, generally, but I think it depends on one's mood.

 

crosby stills and nash without a doubt

 

S&G weren't in the byrds or the hollies. The Croz was kicked out of the byrds for being too wild and back then the Byrds were known for being wild and were the hottest thing around... so that kinda makes him... kick ass. I've said it before, he put a hole through his septum from the coke and still made it this far and only a liver transplant and short jailtime for coke/crack? Plus, he got Melissa Etheridge pregnant in 1995? (he was a sperm donor and she happened to get his sperm, as she and her partner wanted to have a child) and was busted for possesion of weed in New York last year. Neil Young and Stephen Stills played with Buffalo Springfield (as well as Dallas Taylor, CSN(Y)'s former drummer.

Stephen busted a guitar over Neil's head over arguments about who was going to sing what songs (Stephen couldn't stand Neil's voice/singing). Finnigan has been on Organ since... what, 72, 73, or 74? Neil left while doing Stills-Young Band with Stephen. Mike Finnigan is still on the B3 and David found out he had a son when he was getting his liver transplant. Now James Raymond (Croz's son) and Jeff Pevar got together with David and fromed CPR, after he had his liver transplant, etc. Their tour was fucking amazing last year. The lights are great, but nothing like Phish or the Allmans.

I say CSN(Y) all the way.

 

I can't choose. Neither is better, they're just different.

 

i say simon & garfunkle, they give me such happy vibes, i mean dont get me wrong i do love CSNY but i'd pick simon & garfunkle over them any day of the week.

 

I don't much like Young's voice either.

 

CSN, with or without Y, is waaay better than S&G in my opinion

 

Anybody catch Simon & Garfunkel's reunion tour last year?

 

Crosby Stills Nash & Young is my choice of this limited choice of votes..

 

i love them both . i have enough love to go around

 

S&G only because some of CSN(Y) songs are too busy. If you took the best S&G song and put it up against CSN(Y)'s best song, CSN(Y) all the way!!! But if u look at each band as a whole and take the ratio of good songs to band songs, id have to go with S&G.