First, size questons will not die. Too many people, men and women, are curious. Socond, every woman is different. They may have different size vaginas, amounts of lubrication, and have different pain/pleasure thresh holds. Last, it is all opinion. Personally, I get turned on by women that like larger cocks, just like dances in pajamas said, "True, I prefer bigger dicks, but"......... I like women that have the same preference as her. It varies from woman to woman, and while a large percentage of women prefer average and just above average, few if any prefer small. Last, it is OK for some women to prefer a larger penis, and some do! It's all a matter of opinion.
I would have to agree on the fact that it isn't the size that matter... it's definately what you can do with it, thin or short, if you can, accomplish the main goal that's what really matters... Also... personally... having something humongous stuffed in there isn't fun at all anyways.